Saturday 22 February 2014

19. Bridge Too Far

Bridge too far
22nd February 2014
As you know, this blog narrates the story of an attempt to help save the lives of mothers and babies in rural Tanzania. The problem is that the more story there is to tell, the less chance I seem to get to tell it. In the midst of responding to an expanding network of inspiring, encouraging, and well-grounded support, sometimes getting round to narrating the next blog at the end of a day’s g-mailing can turn out to be a bridge too far.

(‘G-mailing’, by the way, for future generations who read this blog after finding a copy of it saved on an electronic papyrus clutched to my chest within my sarcophagus, along with money to pay the boatman, and some cheese-and-pickle sandwiches to avoid the lunch queues on the other side, was not, as you might have thought, the process of sending mail at exactly the speed of sound. It was in fact a device used in the early twenty-first century for enabling you to get through more correspondence on the slow train to Euston via Milton Keynes, than either Milton or Keynes managed in their lifetime.)

Anyway, today the g-mailing is taking a back seat whilst I attempt a blogging bonanza, to help bridge the communication gap between our wildly varying existences on this increasingly small planet.

Talking of bridges, one of the (barely credible) stories awaiting narrating is the collapse of the Berega Bridge,   (Google Earth 6°11'20.21"S  37° 8'28.26"E), in a flash-flood on the Mgugu River on January 21st. The rainfall in Berega itself was only average for the time of year. Far upstream, however, a circle of mountains gathered up the angry waters like Rawhide heading up a herd of feisty steers, and unleashed them on the unsuspecting foothills below. The torrent swept away eleven railway stations, two major bridges, and countless homes and crops. It would have swept away more transport infrastructure, but Tanzania hasn’t got any. The river bed is of course impassable for all but the bravest, and so more than 100,000 sq km of territory is now cut off. To lose your food supply at the same time as losing the potential to replace it is especially worrying for many villagers.





Maybe, however, some unexpected good will come from the turmoil. The President of Tanzania has already visited Berega’s ex-bridge, and apparently a contract has now been signed with an international engineering company to build a new one. Furthermore, the whole episode has raised national awareness of the abysmal transport systems. As a result, President Kikwete recently met England’s very own Nick Clegg, and asked for the UK to donate some old locomotives to populate Tanzania’s railway. The Thin Controller responded with a commitment of sorts, which of course is as good as money in the bank. Or in this case, rolling stock on the tracks. And it is painfully needed: Last year, due to dilapidation, Tanzanian rail only managed to transport 2% of the anticipated shipments. Even had it managed the entire lot, its meagre 4000 km of railway, (in a country with 5,185 km of borders and coastline), would have left many of the loads woefully distant from their destination. (“So you want some goods shipped from Paris to Prague? No problem. Just drop them off at Marseilles, and we will take them all the way to Venice, whence you can pick them up. Except if they happen to be part of the 98% of shipments for which Venice was a bridge too far, in which case you can pick them up from Marseilles. Alternatively, and this is only a suggestion, leave them in Paris, and then at least you will know where they are.”)

It is not surprising, then, that the majority of haulage in Tanzania is performed on the roads. There are about a dozen inter-city roads in Tanzania – one main cross-roads every few hundred kilometres. There are almost no dual carriageways. Duel carriageways, on the other hand, are far too common: this happens when your eye was momentarily diverted from the road by a Masai warrior on his mobile phone, perhaps buying a lion-trap on eBay, and you suddenly realise that two trucks are hurtling towards you, playing chicken. A chicken, ironically, (well a thin one, anyway), would have survived the encounter, as plenty of Tanzanian highways are sensibly of two-truck-and-a-fat-chicken width. But not two-truck-and-your-chosen-means-of-conveyance. It is rare to do the Dar to Morogoro run without seeing at least three cars in a ditch.


The other death-seeking road-occupant is the ubiquitous minibus. More than half of Tanzania’s vehicles are some sort of bus or coach. There are no timetables – the first one to come takes the passengers, and the first one to get to the destination gets the prime pick-up for the homeward run. It will not amaze you to learn, then, that despite having fifty times fewer motor vehicles on the road per capita compared to the UK, Tanzania has seven times the fatality rate. The moral is: only travel with a seasoned Buddhist monk driver, in a strong car, with a whale song tape creating a sense of bien-etre to keep you calm in a crisis – and look both ways before crossing a bridge.

Of course the majority of river crossings are too far from the main road to need to worry about trucks and minibuses. The main form of transport on the dirt roads is the motorbike, and in every village someone will be selling pints of fuel in old coke bottles stacked up on a makeshift counter by the roadside, getting worryingly hot in the sun. When motorbikes are the only transport bar ox cart, then if you came out without your oxen, you have little option.





The motorbike is indeed the principle way that a woman in need would access the hospital, but ironically those most in need are those furthest from the hospital, who are usually the poorest. An average fare from a village forty or fifty kilometres and three rivers away might be 10,000 Tanzanian Shillings – £4. Not much to you or I, but the price might double in a night-time emergency, and a little extra is added for the sister or mother sitting second pillion. Her role is to oversee safe arrival, to give blood and make food, and, for the unfortunate, to take home the body. The final price of a single ride might be as much as £10 – a week’s wages for most – and even then, in the rainy season, they have to hope that the roads and rivers will be passable. For these reasons many women in the remoter areas simply leave it too late, hoping that the bleeding will stop, or that the baby will eventually come. When finally they realise that they will die without help, they collect the fare from friends and relatives, say a poignant goodbye to the children, and set off to cross the most important bridges of their life, hoping that none of them will be too far.

The project EMBRACE will aim to saves these lives, and is about to take its first steps – the mapping of the roads to Tunguli and Mnafu and beyond. We need to know that we are going to the right places, and we need to be able to measure what we are doing: are we indeed making things better? Are women-in-need really coming in to hospital and going home with healthy babies? When we know the names of the villages, we can begin to check routinely the hospital records, as to whether and how the women from each community arrive. And so we begin with a driver, a camera and a GPS machine. Every mile or two he stops: Who lives here? What are the names of the villages? How many mothers of under-5s? Where do they deliver their babies? The results are entered both on Google Earth and on living maps. It is surreal that 160 years after David Livingstone, we are treading laboriously in his footsteps to produce the first ever accurate map. When we have finished the mapping, we might hope that EMBRACE will be ready to begin.

The project is now taking more detailed shape, under the influence of many good minds, and if you want to see what can be achieved by this type of approach in remote and isolated parts of Africa, check out this heart-warming video:


If EMBRACE can achieve the same seismic shifts in attitude and culture, it will be the start of a new era of hope for many women. A pre-requisite, however, is the maintenance of high standards at Berega Hospital, where key new players are beginning to make their presence tell in many important ways. You will remember I hope that Ahmed Ali is the obstetrician currently at Berega, and that his wife Elizabeth is a midwife tutor whom we hope will go out with Ahmed on the next stay. I will say more next time of their contribution, and especially of Ahmed’s determined and enlightened enhancement of standards in obstetrics. In this he is now to be helped by Sion’s acceptance of the role of Deputy Chief Medical Officer, with a remit for clinical standards.


      

Many others are helping shape the vision – Ammalife, Mission Morogoro, BREAD, Hands4Africa, Diocese of Worcester, KOFIA, and also new players just emerging. Many individuals, both those from these organisations, as well as others not yet connected, are planning visits to Berega in the year ahead. Exciting times. I hope that they will find the river crossable by then, and the waters tamed. It is thought-provoking that the substance of which Tanzanian health, economy, and agriculture is in most need, is the very one whose excess destroys all three.

An interesting speculation arises with regard to our own extra-ordinarily persistent and widespread water problems in the South and West of England, and especially in the Somerset Levels, or ‘The Bristol Channel’ as it is now known. (The West Country’s answer to Holland, but without the dykes.) Is it any consolation to an erstwhile affluent Somerset Leveller, I wonder, that someone else has got it worse? As she wades waist-deep from her longue to her kitchen, clad in her pink Versace fisherman’s wellies to make an ironic water-based infusion, is she sparing a thought for the flood-swept river beds of rural Tanzania? As she unhitches her occasional-table raft from the door lintel, to make the white-water dash to her dentist in Bath to get her bridge replaced, well aware of the pirate menace that infests the quieter sections of the A367, is she counting her blessings?

I guess that people do not really appreciate what they have. What they truly do appreciate is the lack of sudden change to what they have. (Or rather they would do, if it were not the case that such appreciation is often retrospective.) Interestingly, this even seems to apply when the sudden change is apparently for the good – winning the lottery is necessarily more tumultuous than not doing so, and by no means guarantees a happier existence. (I have even thought about setting up an alternative ‘Zen Lotto’, in which the top prize is free entry to the following week’s Lotto.)

I guess that my most tumultuous sudden change in recent years was my two months in the sausage-and-malbec-deprivation chamber of Africa. A little before that, I had been happily scribbling away my retirement, vaguely aware of a niggling and nudging in my conscience that maybe I still had a caesar or two left in me. Then suddenly I am doing them. One moment I am living a heady life, pork-and-leeking at will, and washing down the day with Argentina's plummiest. A flash of Kismet's prestidigitation, and I am saving lives in a forgotten corner of a different century. It happened too quickly for me to object. Had I been rational, perhaps I might have been put off by the absurdity of the ambition: to build a bridge to women living in a mediaeval African culture in mud-hut villages 5000 miles away. I might have thought, and so might you, that this was too far-flung to reach, too far-reaching to meddle with, too far-fetched to countenance, and too far-ranging to bridge. Too far?

No.



Friday 14 February 2014

For reference: EMBRACE - a layman's summary

EMBRACE Project summary
Empowering Women & Babies to Receive Adequate Care & Equality

It strikes me that there is a need to say very clearly what we are trying to do with the EMBRACE project. 

Please consider donating a regular sum, and I will send you regular updates.

Purpose of EMBRACE
EMBRACE attempts to save the lives of mothers in childbirth, and of children under 5.

In the process, it hopes to bring sustainable and multi-faceted enrichment to the lives of impoverished Tanzanian villages, (starting with Tunguli and Mnafu).

A key feature of this process will be empowerment and education of women.

What will happen in EMBRACE?
Community Health Workers (CHWs) working out of Berega hospital and within a bespoke maternal-child health community team, will engage with the community of Tunguli to foster the development of women’s groups in the wider community. Such groups will draw in (for instance) pregnant women, mothers of young children, and Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs). The composition and setting up of the groups will follow established evidence of what works.

They will also link with influential villagers, and will ensure that each group has a local ‘champion’ – a Village Health Worker (VHW), who will help drive the project in each community. 

The community group, along with the VHWs, TBAs and the CHWs themselves, will seek first to explore the roots of the problems of maternal and under-5 mortality. This in turn will result in identification of needs beyond health, including tackling education, transport, water, sanitation, food, agronomy, family planning and poverty. This will lead to exploring locally-developed solutions, initially to deal with safe childbirth, and secondly safe child-rearing.

The extended EMBRACE support network, working each to their own strength but in harmony with the whole, will then seek to turn those solutions into reality, using well-judged, well-executed and sustainable methodologies, (eg growth charts; sanitation systems; immunisations; protected wells; affordable emergency transport; family planning; food and cash-crop plantations; malaria prevention; anaemia prevention; TBA education; female education groups; etc.)

During the process, EMBRACE will attempt to measure the effects of the programme, and to learn lessons, initially for the EMBRACE project in the community of Mnafu.

The whole programme will be against a backdrop of enhanced and regularly checked clinical standards in the hospital, within plans for future training of Berega’s own Clinical Officers – front line clinical staff both in community and hospital.

Why EMBRACE?
Community mobilisation and participation works – especially when women are empowered:
The Lancet, Volume 372, Issue 9642, Pages 962 - 971, 13 September 2008

However, unsupported it can be slow, and can identify needs way beyond the remit of the project sponsors. EMBRACE will be ready to meet all those needs arising from the mobilisation of the community, which impinge on maternal and child mortality. This will be done in a synchronised way, with measurement of results, and plans for up-scaling to the wider territory of Berega Hospital.

This similar project in Malawi has had inspiring results:

Thursday 13 February 2014

For reference: A truly wonderful video

The EMBRACE programme (Empowering Women & Babies to Receive Adequate Care & Equality) intends to go into rural Tanzanian villages who have nothing, and make a sustainable difference.

Impossible?
Check out this video, and if you do not cry with the loveliness of it, you can have your money back:


http://vimeo.com/12427420

It has all the elements, and it works:
empowering women; nutrition; local problem identification and local solutions; VHWs, (they call them HSAs); early transport solutions for pregnant women; local economic growth; female education; and mobilising the men!